New Jersey · High School
Nutley High School
14 athletes. 5 years. 4 colleges.
Every athlete Nutley High School has sent to college football, basketball, and track over the last 5 years. Verified against live NCAA rosters. Located in Nutley, NJ.
Rising
Football
D3
11
5yr
Emerging
W. Basketball
D3
3
5yr
How feeder tiers work
Tiers are percentile rankings across every U.S. high school for a given sport and college division, measured over the last 5 years.
Elite
Top 2% of U.S. high schools in this sport and division.
Strong
Top 10% (excluding elite schools).
Rising
Top 25% (excluding elite and strong schools).
Emerging
At least one verified placement in the 5-year window.
Football is ranked separately for FBS (top-level D1) and FCS (D1-AA). Every other sport uses a single D1 tier. Tiers recompute weekly as new college roster data lands.
Pipeline scoreboard
14
Total placements
verified college athletes
4
Unique colleges
programs recruited from
2
Sports represented
Led by football
5yr
Rolling window
2021 to 2025
Destinations
Which colleges have recruited the most players from Nutley High School?
These are the programs actually pulling athletes from this roster. Ranked by verified placements over the last 5 years. Click any college to see your fit score against that program.
Football
→D3Rising feeder11
total placements
Nutley High School is ranked as a rising feeder for football D3. The colleges below have actually received athletes from Nutley High School over the last 5 years.
Women's Basketball
→D3Emerging feeder3
total placements
Nutley High School is ranked as an emerging feeder for women's basketball D3. The colleges below have actually received athletes from Nutley High School over the last 5 years.
Notable Alumni
Who are the current Nutley High School alumni on college rosters?
Real athletes playing right now. Scraped from live college rosters this week. Not self-reported, not seven years old, not fabricated.
Brandon Lucia
Football · 2025
Montclair State
Billy Searle
Football · 2025
Wilkes
CAbigail Scheidel
Women's Basketball · G · 2023
Muhlenberg
Frankie Kokos
Football · TE · 2022
Misericordia
Abigail Scheidel
Women's Basketball · G · 2021
Muhlenberg
1 more Nutley High School alumni are on college rosters right now.
Want to see all 6?
Unlock the full alumni listFree forever · No credit card · Under 90 seconds
Frequently Asked
Questions we get about Nutley High School
What is Nutley High School's college recruiting track record?
Nutley High School in Nutley, NJ has sent 14 athletes to college programs across football, basketball, and track in the last 5 years. Pipeline data is verified against 1,900+ NCAA and NAIA athletic rosters.
Where does this Nutley High School recruiting data come from?
RawRecruit aggregates data from first-party scraping of 1,900+ college athletic rosters across football, basketball, and track. Each athlete's high school is matched against the NCES federal high school database using a state-disambiguated fuzzy matching algorithm. Tier badges are computed from percentile rankings over a rolling 5-year window.
How can athletes from Nutley High School get recruited by college programs?
Athletes from Nutley High School can use RawRecruit's Fit Score algorithm to find personalized matches across 1,900+ schools. RawRecruit analyzes athletic fit, academic fit, positional need, geographic proximity, and cultural fit -- plus the HS pipeline data shown here -- to recommend realistic targets and identify recruiting opportunities.
Your turn
You're not
Nutley High School's pipeline.
You're your own.
See which of the 1,900+ schools are looking for an athlete with your size, speed, grades, and position. Not every school on this page. The right schools for you.
Get my free Fit ScoreFree forever · No credit card · Under 90 seconds
Built by Kevin Monangai, who guided his brother Kyle from overlooked recruit to the Chicago Bears 2025 draft.